Blaming the Government For Everything

McClatchy has an interesting piece up about the increasing popularity of tattoos in China in recent years (h/t to Danwei). It’s a pretty interesting read, and apparently lots of Chinese people are getting tattoos in foreign languages, so hopefully in a few years we can look forward to seeing English tattoos that make as little sense as the English t-shirts everyone is wearing — or as little sense as most of the Chinese tattoos back home.

Wanting to provide some background, the author (Tim Johnson) delves a bit into the history of tattoos in China [emphasis added]:

Tattoos have been around for nearly a millennium in China. Perhaps the most famous one graced the back of Yue Fei, a famous general in the Southern Song Dynasty (1127-1279 A.D.) whose back read: “Serve the country loyally.” Legend has it that his mother ordered the tattoo as inspiration. Under recent decades of Communist Party rule, however tattoos have been largely taboo. Soldiers and police officers must be ink-free. Sports stars rarely have them. And employers discriminate against those with tattoos, thinking they signal a criminal bent.

This is, at best, extremely misleading. Johnson gets points for knowing about Yue Fei, but then strongly implies that the reason tattoos have been taboo in recent years is because of “Communist Party rule”, and that before the CCP, they were popular. That isn’t true at all.

Tattoos have existed in China for millennia, yes, but they were never a very popular form of aesthetic expression. Why? Because they were primarily a form of punishment used to mark convicted criminals. What makes Yue Fei’s tattoo so famous is, among other things, that it was so out of place at the time. The cool kids didn’t have tattoos back in Yue Fei’s day, or at any time between then and now.

If association with criminals wasn’t bad enough (in modern times, many Chinese gangs help perpetuate this negative association via gang tattoos shared by their members), there are other aspects of Chinese culture that make tattoos taboo without any help from Communism. For example, as traditionally one’s body is considered as having come from one’s parents, intentionally marking it with tattoos is considered a sign of disrespect by many, even today.

Johnson’s piece implies that some sort of change in cultural perceptions about tattoos came along with the CCP, but one suspects a statistical comparison would find there are more Chinese people with tattoos now than there were in 1948. The CCP censors plenty, but Tim Johnson missed the boat completely here — this isn’t a censorship thing, it’s a cultural thing. The CCP and its tattoo policies undoubtedly have much less to do with tattoos being taboo than these longstanding cultural beliefs, but nothing sells a story quite like the Communist Party doing something creepy. Never mind that, this time, they didn’t really do anything at all.

Advertisements

0 thoughts on “Blaming the Government For Everything”

  1. I don’t believe Queen Elizabeth II has tattoos on her body. She must be a Chinese commie agent. Perhaps Obama is one, too.

    That is why I said once on his blog that he would never work for the New York Times (not that the Times is the model for every other paper).

    He recently created one of the most ridiculed China pieces by publishing a paranoid laowai’s letter about how the commies wouldn’t let the public buy powerful computers because he wasn’t able to buy one (only worth 10,000 yuan) off the shelve in Henan. It was debunked by nearly every blogger who commented there.

    Like

  2. Furthermore, what would the CCP gain from banning tattoos? It seems like most foreign papers just send a reporter over here and don’t care if he/she knows anything about China. Coverage like this will certainly endear Chinese readers (not that I suspect there are many) to the wonderful thing called freedom of the press.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s